In this episode, consultant, speaker, author, and professor Mark Schaefer shares his thoughts on how to remain authentic and effective marketers in the age of AI. Read this edition here: https://jollysearch.com/newsletter/82-two-things-ai-cant-copy/
If you're in the marketing business, you're dwelling in a pandemic of dull and AI is really just adding to that. Hey everybody, welcome back to Jolly's TL;DR. And today, Mark, I'm so grateful you're here. We have Mark Schaefer, who is a speaker, a consultant, an author, not a one-time author. You've written 12 books and your latest is how AI changes your customers. So that's what I'd love to dive into today. Awesome. Glad to be here. I'm glad you're here. You I didn't mention you also teach at Rutgers and the University of Tennessee. Although we keep these pretty short, I really want them to be educational.
Honestly, I learn a lot on each of these. And you teach in a lane that's right up our alley. You teach digital marketing and AI and we're all about SEO and AI search. So, I just want to make sure we're speaking the same language here to get started. How do you defi define, excuse me, the term AI sloth? That's a term that's really tossed around a lot. For me, it means lazy AI, right? I mean, so one of the things I I talk about in uh in Audacious, which is another book I wrote last year, Audacious, the subtitle is how humans win in an AI marketing world.
So I refer to this research, Greg, that um shows that about twothirds of all advertising and marketing campaigns out there are just uh are boring. they they register no emotional reaction to customers. And the people that created this research were just utterly amazed at how bad most advertising and and marketing is. Um and uh they they they said if there was a CEO of the entire marketing industry, they'd be fired because the results are just so bad. So really, if you're in the marketing business, you're dwelling in a pandemic of dull. And AI is really just adding to that because that's the AI slop part, right? It's it's where people are um just taking the shortcut.
They're not doing the work. There's no human in the loop. There's no human creativity. There's no context for the customer. I saw an example yesterday. It was one of the most egregious errors I've ever seen. Um, they had to shut down every Starbucks in South Korea, more than 2,000 stores because the marketing people in the company created a marketing campaign to celebrate Tank Day. Now, what's Tank Day? Tank Day was a a holiday. They made up with AI. They said, "Okay, what would be a good holiday, a new holiday we could create in South Korea?" Well, what they didn't know, this was totally out of context.
Tank Day was a day many years ago when the government was trying to oppress the citizens and sent tanks into the streets. And they made an ad to celebrate Tank Day of all things because it was just AI slop, right? So this is lazy AI. It is adding to the noise. It is adding to the confusion. It is adding to the pandemic of D. Yeah, that's I'm recording from China and that would I can just totally imagine how horrible that could go wrong here as well. Right. Right. Same kind of thing. Oh jeez. Um, okay. But at the same time, you put out a really great blog post.
You you asked Claude and you had like the most elaborate prompt I've ever seen. To be honest, I think most people need to up their prompt game, but I won't read the whole prompt, but there was a great quote Claude gave you a response and said, "Authenticity is being industrialized." Yeah. If we can't tell the difference, there is no difference. It was among other push back that Claude gave you. But you said in your conclusion that we we still need more companies to protect humans who are willing to put their name on what I would you you called spiky content. Um I it's thoughtprovoking content. Obviously there's a there's a fine line.
We don't want to go into tank day. Uh when that's that's going to be our new mantra. Don't don't be tank day. Don't be just don't be tank day. Uh, do you have any suggestions for our our in-house colleagues that want to wade through the bureaucracy to get approval to do something a little more out there, not that far out there? Yeah. Well, look, you know, this is a really hard problem and I've worked in corporate bureaucracies either inside or with them uh my entire career. So I know this is a hard problem and I know cultural change is really really difficult and so a couple observations.
So I mean marketing has changed so much the the sort of content that's going to win in in with you know AI search or or or SEO search these days. I mean it's just got to be different than what we've done in in the past. And um one of the things I've taught in my classes is this idea called spiky content. Spiky content. It's it's based in facts, but it's an opinion that can be debated. It can be it's it's defensible because you know you're adding your opinion to something.
So, let's say you see this blog post and or you see some article or you YouTube video about the three ways AI is changing search and you say, "Well, wait a minute. I think there's a fourth way." So, you create content around that. That is spiky content. It's based in facts. You're adding your own opinion. It's debatable, but it's defensible. All right. Now, and and and sort of to kind of build on where you're getting at there, it's not reckless, right? It's not offensive. You're not trying to hurt somebody. You're attacking problems. You're not attacking people. Um, and I I I think it really gets down to this. If you're working with leaders who really want to stay at the forefront of this, and that's their job, by the way, they need to push forward.
They should be very open to these ideas. They they should be challenging you for new ideas to help your content stand out, right? That's the right kind of culture. If you're living in a culture that doesn't really support that kind of of of of innovation, you've really got two choices. Number one would be internal education. And I'm talking about the top leaders of your company. The only way the culture is going to change there's is is through the leaders. There's no such thing as a grassroots cultural change. the people that control the budget and the strategy, they must support you.
They must understand what's going on in the world. And so I mean one of the things I've done at at big companies is I've suggested like a lunch and learn program where you bring the top executives together you know maybe once a month and you you you you address um just one of these topics about how the world is changing so that they understand how that they how they can support your organization. The second option, and I don't say this lightly, is quit.
Because I I I mean, if if the if the culture just isn't ready to make these changes, and you know these changes are needed, you probably need to go find some place where you're going to be more successful and more productive and happier. Yeah, fair enough. uh you know we're we're a small agency but even we sometimes have rules that I think are not as supportive as they could be to the people working with us and I I always try to see their point of view and at the same time I always want to support them and say like you know if if sometimes our company isn't what's right for your career you also have to think about yourself here what yeah what's the right direction for you um okay so just speaking of our agency Another component of our audience are folks like us. They run service businesses.
So maybe a lot of your students are in this. They hope to provide services as freelancers or future business owners. But we also are seeing a race to the bottom in our industries. I mean when haven't we, right? But AI is has accelerated this. Yeah. And I'm curious if if you have any practical suggestions for us without delivering AI slop for ways that whether it's in terms of market positioning or or in service fulfillment. Yeah. We can keep providing a premium service but take advantage of the laborsaving benefits of AI. Not do lazy AI. Yeah. I mean, I I I don't want to uh come across as someone who's anti- AI.
I mean, I I love AI. I mean, I I use it every hour of the day. Um, and I use it in many, many creative ways. You mentioned, you know, sort of the creative way I used it in this blog post to challenge me about some of my own philosophies around marketing and it really came up with some good ideas. So I when when it comes to positioning and branding, I I think there's only two things that we can own. Uh there's only two things that that our competitors can't keep copying.
So in the audacious book that we mentioned, I did have a case study there on a on on a on the fastest growing beverage brand in America. It's called Liquid Death. It's a crazy company that has attacked the water market through just really completely audacious and hilarious marketing. And the founder of that company was not obsessed with water. He saw an opportunity that water like most industries Greg are in this pandemic of dull. There was they needed to shake it up. And so he created this just absolutely audacious brand. Now there's a great quote in this book that I think is relevant uh to any business today. He said look there's absolutely nothing we could do with our product that CocaCola or Pepsi couldn't copy.
They, you know, if we want to make it, you know, add muscles, they could do it. If we said it helps you sleep better, they could do it. If we added new flavors and vitamins, they could do it. Uh, there's absolutely nothing they can't copy except our brand. That's it. So, what is a brand? What is a brand? A brand is creating an emotional expectation between you and your customers. And in the long term, that separates you from your competitors because you you're not a commodity anymore. You stand for something. You mean something. When I said the word liquid death, I I automatically saw a little smile come across her face, right?
because you instant recognition. Yeah. You recognize this as something that's playful and I mean the younger generation are just embracing this cuz they're just waiting for something new. Now in the world of SEO uh and uh and in a lot of marketing today it's performanceoriented and that is perfectly great. It's perfectly fine, right? There's a lot of pressure on getting the ROI for your marketing dollars, but is but what is sometimes overlooked by a lot of agencies is the importance of the brand. It's the only thing you own.
It's the only thing your competitors can't copy except number two mentioned there's two things and that is how you treat your customers, right? how you build these relationships, how you build this trust, how you treat your customers. I have a saying in my business, uh that you know we do the right thing even when it hurts. And that's painful sometimes, but I want that reputation that you know when my customers have had when something has gone wrong, something has gone downhill, you know, something has happened that was unanticipated, I stand by them. I do the right thing. And I I I think um you know I have a reputation for integrity. I have a reputation for being forwardthinking.
I have a reputation for being trustworthy. And that is um that that's not just what I stand for. That's how I treat my customers. And I think those are the two things we can own, Greg, to really decommoditize our businesses. If if an SEO or now we call ourselves GEO, sometimes agency owners listening, I I'd love to underscore that second point. I there's of course been times where we haven't served our own clients in the way that we wanted to, but we always strive to find an amicable solution.
And we had a situation earlier this year, for instance, where there was a miscommunication and a campaign ran for not one but three months longer than a client had intended. We didn't feel we got a clear cancellation. They didn't feel they had a clear unpause uh message sent. And the only right thing to do in that case is find a way that they can walk away feeling that we were as generous as we could be with all the services delivered and refund that they requested. There's no other way to do it. I always tell people who are understandably skeptical of SEOs. Uh we we don't have the best rep sometimes. Yeah. I tell them like we're we're not here for the quick sale.
We we've been in business 10 years and we want to be here another 10 at least. So yeah, that all we have is our name. Exactly. It's exciting. Yeah. And I I think that is an important opportunity in the SEO field. I mean I' I've worked with a lot of questionable people. Yes. I know. Uh and and left those people as well. Exactly. Uh I I that's how I describe it to my lovely wife. She's like, I think you you're too nice. You get take advantage of. I'm like someone double crosses me. I just don't know them anymore. It's okay. But that's the way it goes. Yeah, you you only have your name.
Um you mentioned, you know, I'm I'm going to lean into our little SEO industry here. Mark, you you mentioned AI search. Um curious of your take on the timeline. Everyone has their own view, but where are we in terms of slowly transitioning either away from or at least now having to incorporate AI search as a as a primary share of the market? Yeah. Well, I just saw a blog post come across uh my my feed uh today. Um and it was sort of shocking because um uh you know I the the when I teach in my classes sort of the latest number that I've shown is that um about uh you know 60% of the search now is like you know no click kind of search. Right. Right.
And just on I mean we all know you know Rand Fishkin and Rand had a new article today that said now it's you know it's it's less than it's it's a it's even less than that. It's it's like maybe you know uh something like we're down to like 30% or something like that. So um and and you know even you know even Google is AI right? And um AI mode. Yeah. AI and and and so I I I want to introduce uh an idea here that I think would be very relevant and and interesting for for SEO and the people working on what are you calling it AEO or AGO or something right? What do you call it? What do you want to call it? Yeah. What do you want to call it?
I don't know if it's official yet. But one of the things I wrote about in um the uh how AI changes your customers book is look I mean people are relying on AI more and more for their search. I wrote in the book that um we're all in the diaper business now. And what I mean by that is I have a new grandchild. He's now one years old. He's a very bright, wonderful child and he is an expert pooper. He goes through a lot of diapers and he is the customer for the diapers, but he's not the decision maker. So to sell diapers, you've got to appeal to his caretakers, to mom and dad. Now they're the decision makers.
What's going on with AI? Many many people are abdicating their decision-making process to AI. Your end customer is not the decision maker increasingly. And the trust in AI is going up not just for small decisions but big decisions like what house do I buy? What city do I move to? What college do I go to? Right now you know you're in the middle of the business. It's really, really hard and somewhat mysterious to get on top of these AI referrals. So, I want to suggest an an alternative view that I talk about in the book and it's this idea of AI overrides. I think it could be part of your consultancy.
So look, I recently went to Paris. Uh took a trip to Paris and like everybody these days, I go to AIS. I planned my trip. It did a perfect perfect job, right? And I followed the itinerary almost exactly, you know, almost exactly as it said, you know, it it it did a fantastic job, except I said I want to fly on Delta Airlines and I want to stay in these certain hotels. Now, this gets back to our the conversation we just had about branding. Branding is more important than ever. It is an override for AI.
If you mean so much to your customers, they're going to say, "Look, you give me an itinerary or give me a solution, but I want to use these people or I want I'm going to use this company, right? Or I want to buy these shoes because I've always bought these shoes because they mean something to me." So branding is more important than ever ever. It's an override to AI. Now, let's go back to my trip to Paris. Friend of mine says, "Hey, I understand you're going to Paris, and I know you have to eat gluten-free. Let me recommend a bakery in Paris that's gluten-free." So, I not only went once, I went twice. When SEO recommends something or AI recommends something, you know, I'll think about it. But when a human being recommends it, you do it right.
And there's, you know, there's a very famous statistic is it's 92%. This was a number that came up from Neielson a couple years ago. 92% of of of American adults will believe a recommendation from a person even if it's a stranger over any advertising over any marketing over any search over any AI right this is another override word of mouth marketing and again it's it's it's it means doing something for your customers just like you said all right you had this problem with your customer and you stood by them. They're going to recommend you to others. That's the best marketing you can ever have.
Completely unadulterated by AI, completely untouched by AI. You don't need a content marketing plan for that. You just need to do the right thing. You need to create something so worthy, so interesting that your customers can't wait to talk about you. Right? So that's that's another key idea in this very competitive world. Yeah. And it works adversely, too. I I as you can probably already tell, Mark, I don't shy away from trying to help people learn from my mistakes. Uh we we had a period six years ago where we were newer at this and we were growing too fast. And we just stumbled on client service.
And wouldn't you know it, uh for a couple years, referrals just trickled to almost nothing. And it's just the way it goes. It wasn't it wasn't loud. It was just whispers or or quiet conversations that were confident were existing in the background to us. But for other people, those experiences were very real. And so we we had to slowly rebuild uh from that learning lesson. So I totally agree. Um, I I have uh really enjoyed talking about uh AI search and SEO, but I I wanted to ask you, I watched your announcement of selling the marketing companion. You you ran this podcast for over 13 years and had more than three million downloads.
Uh that's something I could I could hope to come close to in another 10 years of doing this. I don't know. Uh but you described one of the reasons I think all of us can resonate with in any project we've done a long time is you needed to reclaim some time. So you needed to release this project that you've been doing for so long. And I'm curious um for those of us I think a lot of us are still struggling to make time to incorporate AI into our workflow without just slipping into that easy AI slop lazy AI. Yeah. So, I'm just really curious like what what you learned in the process of reclaiming your time.
Um, and like how did you make full use of that new time that you did reclaim? Uh, well, you know what an interesting point you make that it's hard to make time for AI. It's hard to make time to save time. Yeah, it's a it's an interesting perspective. Um, and you and and look, you know, that is important. You've got your to roll up your sleeves and and learn how to use this stuff and and experiment with this stuff.
But, um, you know, a big lesson for me is when I was in the corporate world, we used to have this uh this manager in our business and he would he would walk up and down the hall and he would stick his head in people's offices and he'd say, "What are your three things?" And what he meant by that is you need to really focus on the three critical things that drive your business. And you either need anything else that comes across your desk, you need to either delegate it or you need to say no. And boy, I mean it is hard. It is hard to do that. But that is absolutely essential. And especially when we get into AI and marketing, there's so many things that we love to do. Maybe we love to tweak our website. Maybe we love to experiment with, you know, AI music or AI video or something like that.
It can be intoxicating. And if you're spending a lot of time on that stuff, even if you love it, maybe you need a question and say, "Is this driving my business? What are the three things driving my business? What are the three things I need to accomplish today? And until you accomplish those things, you don't do anything. And you've got to stay really, really focused. I I mean, I get this question a lot because I do a lot. I'm a very productive person. I'm a very prolific person, but I couldn't do any of it if I just said yes to everything. Right. You've got to focus on the three things that drive your business.
And that has served me very well. Yeah. I think that's great. great guardrails for AI. Like many of us, I have plenty of chat sessions with Claude. I have plenty of cool scheduled tasks that I've created, but I need to audit my use of time each time I get excited about spinning up a new scheduled task. Yeah. I mean, even using AI can take a lot of time, you know, and one of the mistakes I'm making is like, you know, you go, you know, I've been using cloud co-work a lot, right? And so I'll like I'll I'll I'll do a prompt and I'll think and and sometimes I like I hit go too early.
I did it again today actually. Or maybe you didn't get the you and then you can't stop it. You you and now you're waiting for it or you got to exit the thing and you got to start over. Uh so I mean it can really be a big time suck uh to you know to get it right to get the AI right to learn these new tools and and I think that takes discipline too. Yeah completely. Um, Mark, I know you've interviewed people before and so my favorite interview question is always at the end. I'd love to ask is there is there anything I didn't ask that you wanted to share with our audience here and would you please as we wrap up?
Oh, well, I mean the the way I usually end a lot of my uh discussions and and speeches is I think it's my bestselling book. is called marketing rebellion and the subtitle is the most human company wins. That's sort of become my mantra. And I I think I've had to pause and and revisit that in the age of AI when AI can be so convincing. It can be so human and maybe even better than than than most of us in a lot of ways. And I think what I get down to is this. Number one, absolutely the most human company wins. That is what people are always going to crave. The in the future, real humanity is going to be a luxury.
Now, the most human company doesn't necessarily have to be the most human. It can be a combination. It's the right combination. and having that discernment about when do we keep humans in the loop? When is it missionritical to have a real actual carbon-based human in this discussion with our customers? We also have to be careful. You know, we talked about your brand. What are you known for? If you're known for your personal touch, don't go too far in AI. It's going to screw up your brand. you know, even again, you know, if it this seems like, oh my gosh, we could save all this money, be careful about what it does to your brand.
So, I think overall truly the most human company wins, but the company that achieves that will be the right blend of real humans and AI. Awesome, Mark. I learned so much. Uh I I hope people find your resources out there of which as we discussed there are over 12 books now so they should be able to find one. Uh we connected on LinkedIn. Where else can people look you up? Well, it's uh so easy to find me. Uh you don't even have to remember my name. You just have to remember businesses grow. Businesses grow. That's my website. You can find the books that we talked about today. You can find my my blog.
Uh I give away all my best ideas and uh you can find my social connections. I'd love to hear from you. That's awesome. I hope they go to businessgrow.com. Mark, I really appreciate your time. Thank you so much for taking the time. Thank you. Bye, everyone.
We turn the ideas in these videos into AI visibility and Google traffic for our clients. Book a free call and we'll map out what's possible for your brand.